Geek Girls Rule! #63 – An Update, a Review, and the Demise of Minx

Ok, I think I finally have some time to sit and read comics, so expect a report on story lines and what I think, if you all still care. Hedgepigs are settling in, I have discovered and purchased glow-in-the-dark purple yarn, I have introduced another Geek Girl to the joy that is begonias, and rediscovered the joy that is being on the prowl in a nightclub while wearing a vinyl skirt.

The review: As I said a few weeks ago, the Mister and I have been doing some one-on-one gaming using Burning Wheel by Luke Crane. Burning Wheel is not actually designed for one-on-one, but it works well for it. Character creation is less time intensive than GURPS, and resembles Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay, in that you get certain skills for choosing certain “Lifepaths,” an analog to careers, as opposed to going over a huge list of skills and kind of losing your mind over all the neat stuff… Not that I’ve ever done that or anything. Now, coming up with a character concept and trying to reverse engineer it backwards to where you would have had to begun for that Lifepath can be a bit of a pain in the ass, but it’s hardly insurmountable, or really anything more than a minor annoyance.

However, unlike Warhammer FRP, you are not completely useless as a new player character. As much as I adore the world of Warhammer, the frustration of trying to a get a first level character to anything resembling useful drives me absolutely bonkers.  In Warhammer FRP, a first level healer can’t even competently bandage a simple scrape, a first level fighter is lucky not to stab themselves in the foot. My brand new Burning Wheel character held her in own in several fights, without armor, something you’d expect of any character who had devoted her life to assassination as an art form. This does however, lead me to the one thing that drives me crazy about Burning Wheel so far.

I am not a fan of the combat system so far. Hell, I’m not even sure I can accurately describe it in order to convey my disgruntlement. You take the number of attacks and divide them up among three turns, blindly, unaware of your opponent’s intended actions. You have a limited number of types of actions you can take, although your descriptions of how you achieve them are unfettered. It just makes me a touch cranky, particularly waiting for the Mister to finish sorting out his attacks. I get itchy when combat hits and am not enamored of anything leading to delays.  Besides, I do not agree that the blind response adequately mimics actual combat.

I do really like the fluidity of the world. And I love that Burning Wheel has the Monster Burner, that allows you to play monstrous races as player characters. I also like that each time you use a skill, that contributes to its increase, even if you don’t succeed, as opposed to leveling where, as the Mister and friends put it, “I just killed a bunch of goblins, now I can swim and speak Elvish better!” I’m sure I’ll discover more likes and peeves as I play it, but for right now while Burning Wheel is crunchier than I’d choose for anything I would run, it isn’t crunchy enough to run me off. And there’s no alignments. Woot!

Now, on to the demise of DC’s Minx line. I will point you to to my prediction when DC announced it: “…I seriously doubt that the Big Two are going to bring their “A game” to the imprint. It’ll be a lame, half-assed attempt, and when it fails what we’ll get is a whole lot of, “See? We gave you what you wanted and it didn’t sell?”

I hate to say I told you so, but… Well, I did, didn’t I? I wish I could say this surprised me. Actually, I wish I could say that they surprised me by adequately supporting it and making it a success. But I knew it wasn’t going to happen, and so did pretty much every other female comics fan out there.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s